The Weak Case for Torture
I have a confession to make: I watch a fair amount of Fox News, frequent conservative blogs, etc. Most days this isn’t a problem as the slanted noise machine talking points mislabeled as news one gets from these sources are in line with my own Radical Individualist Calvinist Capitalist Stooge beliefs. Occasionally, however, the experience can be a painful one, and the last couple of days, with all the renewed attention on the use of waterboarding and other forms of tor- er, “enhanced interrogation” have been some of the most painful in recent memory.
The latest meme running through these sites is that while it may be honorable to be opposed to torture on principle, we ought to be reasonable and just admit that torture works. Here, for example, is Jonah Goldberg:
I have no objection to the moral argument against torture — if you honestly believe something amounts to torture. But the “it doesn’t work” line remains a cop out, no matter how confidently you bluster otherwise.
-
Archives
- May 2009 (11)
- April 2009 (15)
- March 2009 (15)
- February 2009 (13)
- January 2009 (14)
- December 2008 (6)
- November 2008 (20)
- October 2008 (20)
- September 2008 (15)
- August 2008 (19)
- July 2008 (21)
- June 2008 (26)
-
Categories
- Abortion
- Africa
- America
- Animal Rights
- Capitalism
- Catholic Social Thought
- Catholicism
- Charity
- Children
- China
- Contraception
- Culture
- Death Penalty
- Democracy
- Distributism
- Double Effect
- Driving
- Economics
- Economy
- Ecumenism
- Education
- Election
- Energy
- Environmentalism
- Equality
- ESCR
- Ethics
- Euthanasia
- Evolution
- Family
- Film
- Food
- Foreign Policy
- Global Warming
- Government
- Guns
- Health Care
- History
- Homosexuality
- Humor
- Identity
- Immigration
- Islam
- Israel
- Jews
- Just Wage
- Just War
- Law
- Libertarianism
- Literature
- Marriage
- Media
- Men and Women
- Morality
- Mormonism
- Nationalism
- Nuclear Weapons
- Patriotism
- People
- Philosophy
- Political Theory
- Politics
- Poverty
- Progress
- Quotidian Matters
- Race
- Science
- Scriptire
- Seeing
- Social Security
- Sports
- Statistics
- Stimulus
- Taxes
- Terrorism
- Theology
- Torture
- Trade
- Traffic
- Uncategorized
- Unions
- Voluntary Associations
- Voting
- War and Peace
- Weirdness
- Work
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS